Potty vs Toilet Trainer Seat: Which Should Your Toddler Use First? - My Carry Potty®

Potty vs Toilet Trainer Seat: Which Should Your Toddler Use First?

Posted by Amanda Jenner


Potty or toilet trainer seat? It's the first decision most parents make and it matters less than you'd think, because the majority of children end up using both. The short version: start with a potty if your child is under two and a half or you want to be able to take it out with you. Start on the toilet with a trainer seat and a step if your child is older, copies everyone else in the house, or hates the idea of a potty. Either way, you'll move to the toilet in the end.

Toddler sitting on a trainer seat on the toilet with a step stool

Potty vs trainer seat, in short

  • Most toddlers start on a potty. It's low, steady, theirs, and it goes where they go.
  • A trainer seat is stage two. It shrinks the toilet hole so they can't fall in, and it's how they move on from the potty.
  • Older starters can skip the potty. A confident two-and-a-half or three year old often goes straight to the toilet with a seat and a step.
  • Have both if you can. Potty for the first weeks and for going out, seat for home once they're ready. A matching set makes the switch easier.

"I've found most toddlers gravitate to a potty to begin with. It's smaller, it's closer to the ground, and it's a lot less frightening than climbing up onto a big toilet. The trainer seat comes into its own when they're ready to move on, and if the seat matches the potty, that move feels like the next step rather than starting again."

Amanda JennerAmanda Jenner, ITV's potty training expert

Potty vs toilet trainer seat: side by side

Penguin My Carry Potty

Potty

Good for

  • Younger toddlers, roughly 18 months to 2½
  • Feet flat on the floor, which makes pooing easier
  • Quick access when they're in a hurry
  • Living-room training in the early days
  • Taking out, if it has a lid that seals

Downsides

  • You empty and clean it every time
  • Some children get attached and resist the toilet later
  • Another thing on the floor
Penguin My Little Trainer Seat

Toilet trainer seat

Good for

  • Older starters, 2½ and up
  • Children who want to copy you or a big sibling
  • No emptying: it flushes
  • Moving on from the potty
  • Nursery and school, where there's no potty

Downsides

  • Needs a step stool so feet aren't dangling
  • Your child can't get on without help at first
  • The flush and the height frighten some toddlers
  • Harder to take out and about
  Potty Trainer seat
Typical starting age 18 months to 2½ 2½ and up, or as stage two
Where it lives Wherever your child is On the toilet
Feet Flat on the floor Need a step stool
Cleaning Empty and wipe each time Flush
Out and about Yes, if it has a sealing lid Folding seats only, and you still need a toilet
Independence Can get on and off alone from day one Alone once they can manage the step
Our pick My Carry Potty, £29.99 My Little Trainer Seat, £14.99

Which should your toddler use first?

A

Start with a potty if…

  • Your child is under two and a half
  • They're nervous of the toilet, or of the flush
  • You'll be training in the living room, not the bathroom
  • You're out a lot and want the same potty everywhere
  • They tend to hold poos. Knees-up on a low potty makes pooing easier
B

Start on the toilet with a trainer seat if…

  • Your child is two and a half or older and confident
  • They already want to copy you or an older sibling on the toilet
  • They flatly refuse a potty (it happens, and it's fine)
  • You'd rather not empty a potty
  • Nursery uses toilets, and you want home to match

Pair it with a step stool. Dangling feet make children tense, and a tense child can't poo. Our guide to the best step stools for potty training explains what to look for.

Moving from the potty to the toilet

Most children are ready to try the toilet a few weeks to a few months after they're reliably using the potty. Signs: they're interested in the toilet, they can climb a step, and they're happy to sit on the trainer seat with their clothes on. Then:

  1. Put the trainer seat on the toilet and the step in front, and let them sit fully clothed a few times. No pressure to do anything.
  2. Move the potty into the bathroom so wees happen in the same room as the toilet.
  3. Offer the toilet for the first wee of the day, when they're most likely to go, and praise the sitting whether or not anything happens.
  4. Keep the potty available for a few weeks. Taking it away suddenly leads to holding on.
  5. Poos usually move last. Don't rush that one.

A seat that matches the potty helps more than it sounds like it should. The design your child chose and the colour they know make the toilet feel like theirs too. My Carry Potty, My Little Trainer Seat and My Little Step Stool come in matching characters and pastels, and the three are £54.99 as a set.

Our pickPotty, Trainer Seat & Step Stool set£54.99Shop the set

Potty vs trainer seat questions

Can I skip the potty and go straight to the toilet?

Yes, and plenty of families do, particularly with children who start at two and a half or later. You'll need a trainer seat and a step stool, and you'll lose the option of training in the living room. If your child is nervous of the toilet, a potty is the gentler start.

Is a potty or a toilet seat better for boys?

Either, as long as it has a splash guard at the front and your son sits down to wee to begin with. Standing comes later. Our guide to the best potty for boys covers it.

Do I need a step stool with a trainer seat?

Yes. It lets your child climb up on their own, and it gives their feet somewhere to rest, which is what lets them relax enough to go. A trainer seat without a step is half a solution.

My toddler will use the potty but refuses the toilet. What now?

Don't push. Leave the seat on the toilet, let them sit on it dressed, and let them flush your wees for a while so the noise stops being scary. Then try the toilet for the first wee of the morning only. Our guide to a toddler who's scared of the potty applies to the toilet too.

What about a potty chair or a potty with a built-in seat?

Two-in-one potties with a removable seat that fits the toilet look like a bargain, but the seat part is often flimsy and the potty part is usually bigger and harder to take out. A separate potty and seat that match does the same job better. Our best potty chairs for big toddlers guide covers the larger options.

Whichever you start with, the routine is the same: potty or toilet on waking, after meals and every 30 to 45 minutes, praise the trying, stay calm about accidents. Our day one guide takes you through the first day, and the 10 potty training essentials covers everything else you'll need.

← Older Post Newer Post →

RSS
0 comments

Leave a comment